Whole pie. This is our best-selling pie throughout the year. Our Olallieberry Pie has its very special place in our community. Many years ago, we were introduced to olallieberries on the Gizdich Ranch in Watsonville. After some experimenting with the berries, FATAPPLE'S long time favorite pie was born. A big slice with a generous slab of vanilla ice cream will be unforgettable.

Please order carefully ==Thanksgiving Pie Ordering ends on Fri. 11/21/25== Pick up dates/time during 11/24/25 through 11/28/25 are blocked out.
All cancellations result in a restocking fee equal to 5% of total purchase. Please contact us 48 hours before your pickup day to cancel your purchase. We cannot refund for a product after it has been baked.

Olallieberry Pie

Olallieberry Pie.

Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie.

Raspberry Rhubarb Pie

Raspberry Rhubarb Pie.